Skip to product information
1 of 1

Pie - Lemon Icebox - 10”

Creamy & tart, but not too tart, this pie is perfect for a taste of Summer in the middle of Winter. Like a Key Lime pie, but also NOT like a Key Lime Pie...the best word for it may be refreshing. Old Fashioned Lemon Icebox has a cult following with some of our customers. Try it & join the cult.

This cold pie is stored and served straight from the fridge making it a convenient option. Please don't EVER put this pie in the oven. It also freezes very well

ALLERGY NOTICE - Contains eggs.


Please select the week for which you are pre-ordering only. Selecting inventory from another week may cause part or all of your order to be cancelled and refunded.

Regular price $36.00
Regular price Sale price $36.00

Please schedule your pickup date/time at checkout.

You MUST place a separate order for each pickup date/time. Please don't select items for multiple days on the same order.